Topic: Feature request: Hide, not delete uploads that fail quality check

Posted under Site Bug Reports & Feature Requests

Inspired by the fact that so many of my favorites on E6AI were deleted for "low quality". Hate the artwork I like disappearing on me. Hate it. I don't care if it has six fingers or a lazy eye, just give it back! Ahem...

I don't know if e621ng has that capability, but a bunch of other booru sites definitely do. They do that thing where deleted artwork can be hidden from the frontpage and search results but still be available through a direct link.

Obviously you've got more pressing issues other than tinkering with feature requests right now, so I'll just leave this here for the future.

EMX

Member

I like this idea. Maybe it could still be manually retrievable through a status:hidden search, similar to status:deleted, but most people won't need to see the lower quality stuff, so the site's overall quality won't be negatively affected.

artificialdragon said:
I don't know if e621ng has that capability, but a bunch of other booru sites definitely do. They do that thing where deleted artwork can be hidden from the frontpage and search results but still be available through a direct link.

To answer this. E621 doesn't actually delete images. It just removes the ability for non-staff to see them. Which is helpful for when artists fully take down their works but want to come back later. We saw this with Carpetwurm when he was banned and came back. Only to be banned again. I think it is this way so when someone says, "I'm out," they can look back later and see everything is wiped.

plus one. fortunately i was able to recover applejack wife that was deleted on e6ai and reupload it here and it even got approved

Step in right direction but not enough

Perhaps we should hold off until the admins create a dedicated suggestions thread on the forum?

I've actually had a two-page list of suggestions sitting ready to go for the past two months, originally intended for e6ai. This thread could simply be one of several proposals aimed at addressing the rather absurd upload restrictions on e6ai, so I suppose it makes sense to wait until the admins have got the site launch out of the way before bringing this up.

By the way, have you seen the recruitment thread on the e6ai forum for new moderators and janitors? One of the listed requirements is:

- Detail-oriented

The culprit right there, in the open

They've managed to mess things up before anyone has even been hired. :D

Hiring janitors from among people who are obsessed with nitpicking details that the vast majority of users and viewers couldn't care less about. It'll be amusing to watch how their new site manages to compete for a bigger community and greater popularity once Blep went with a more sensible approach and saw their user base outgrow theirs as a result. :))

I'd give it a year at most before they figure out what's going wrong and decide to revise their own policies too.

updated:
There are some indications that their approach to this will be more sensible than the one on e6ai so I hope both become successful :))


Updated:
No, it's not the site. It's yet another one. The one the e6ai's moderating team goes/went to will probably keep its stupid approach to upload rules (flaws)

Updated