Topic: Suggestion: add "low-quality" or "defect" tags

Posted under Site Bug Reports & Feature Requests

So, we have quality standards for uploads carried over from E6AI.

My suggestion is to tag submissions with specific issues present in the picture - for example, false_signature_(defect) or six_fingers_(defect) - regardless of whether a picture is rejected, approved, or deleted.

This should have a couple of benefits:

- Mods must always specify why a picture was rejected; no ambiguity.
- Artists will know exactly what issues they have to fix for the picture to be approved.
- Viewers can filter out pictures they feel don't meet their quality standards.
- Viewers can tag already uploaded and approved pictures; quality control can be done by community, not just mods.

Since you're implementing an AI auto-tagger, it should also be able to pick up on and tag certain errors - particularly missing limbs and such - and make the janitor's work a little easier that way.

Updated

I like the idea of a 'defect' tag, although not too opinionated about different types of defect tags.

This is a great idea. If moderation is going to be more lenient than e6ai's was, then we're going to need options to refine what we personally see. On the director's side, knowing exactly how to improve would be a great benefit as well

Enkin

Member

Having done a couple revisions already mods did specify exactly what they want changed. On Miku it was a pseudo double iris, and on another it was mismatched fingers. I didn't think too much about either but they were hosted on platforms that were more lax.

Imo already a big improvement over nebulous rejections that e6ai would give, leaving the uploader to waste time looking for some defect to please the overlords. Like this complaint https://8chan.moe/fur/res/6415.html#q14039

The thing about E6AI? Stringent anti-slop rules to the point that they'll remove based on very (autistically) small details. My first submission got removed because of a few specific yet very small details that I didn't even notice when I looked around the image. With all the time I spent for what I considered a mid-level-effort porn generation, I realized that I legitimately would rather 3D-model the entire scene and characters, including rigging, than try and play "spin the RNG wheel in hopes of genning something that pleases the jannies". At that point, I realized that any mistakes on any legitimate art site, or even E621 wouldn't be NEARLY as scrutinized. Shit, I haven't seen such strict-anti-slop measures since elfwood (you know you're old if you remember elfwood).

I like the idea of users deciding if they care about minor errors, but if it was rejected how would users see them? As of now rejected art doesn't go public, everything has to be approved before.

enkin said:
Having done a couple revisions already mods did specify exactly what they want changed. On Miku it was a pseudo double iris, and on another it was mismatched fingers. I didn't think too much about either but they were hosted on platforms that were more lax.

Imo already a big improvement over nebulous rejections that e6ai would give, leaving the uploader to waste time looking for some defect to please the overlords. Like this complaint https://8chan.moe/fur/res/6415.html#q14039

I like the idea of users deciding if they care about minor errors, but if it was rejected how would users see them? As of now rejected art doesn't go public, everything has to be approved before.

You know, crossposting work you find on other public sites is valid and encouraged if you think it'd meet standards here.