Topic: Feature request: Disabling account features to avoid banning stupid users unessassarily.

Posted under Site Bug Reports & Feature Requests

E621 was downright infamous for banning users who simply cannot tag for squat or posted stupid bullshit in the comments like coomerposts, and I figured the best solution to discourage ban evasion if you are going to lock lolisho behind account requirements is to implement the ability to disable these features per account, with true bans being reserved for posting abuse in areas that are more critical to the site.

Sounds good to me. I already see them doing the same song and dance on FG. Hammering down nails wherever they can see them.
I've seen comments that would get swept up on FG posted on Pawbooru without issue, so we'll have to see how Blep handles this.

Updated

kinkock said:
coomerposts

is this when you are being down bad in comments like rule34 comments are? or is this something else?

enkin said:
Sounds good to me. I already see them doing the same song and dance on FG. Hammering down nails wherever they can see them.
I've seen comments that would get swept up on FG posted on Pawbooru without issue, so we'll have to see how Blep handles this.

Wait, so floofgens is implementing the same badly disclosed controversial aggressive policy against coomerposters that e621 has where literal jokes can get you banned? damn.

kinkock said:
Wait, so floofgens is implementing the same badly disclosed controversial aggressive policy against coomerposters that e621 has where literal jokes can get you banned? damn.

like when you comment horny shit like "i wish i was the chair..." and get banned? why is it forbidden there? this sometimes produces funniest shit and if not it still harms no one

xruyi said:
like when you comment horny shit like "i wish i was the chair..." and get banned? why is it forbidden there? this sometimes produces funniest shit and if not it still harms no one

Because it's Da Rules

I encourage you to read them. The reasons for the rules are given, which are reasonable IMO. They may not be to everyone's preference, rules rarely are, but the reasons are there.

cocoa_morsel said:
Because it's Da Rules

I encourage you to read them. The reasons for the rules are given, which are reasonable IMO. They may not be to everyone's preference, rules rarely are, but the reasons are there.

These restrictive commenting rules are from when e6ai was setting everything to be a copypaste from e6ai so they can easily just not apply anymore.
And I think they were the same as e621 so top down from Bad Dragon. (yep word for word) https://e621.net/help/inappropriate_comments

Most boorus aren't nearly trying to be as 'clean facing' while hosting raunchy content. Personally downvotes exist already for people who want to shadowban these comments if the coom-munity doesn't like em we don't need extra moderation wasted on it.

if anything, this kinda rules made comment section on e621 cringe. like everyone trying to be funny but not succeeding. example: picture of someone being fucked in the ass and there is pizza on the picture somewhere and the top rated comment would be "hey i like pineapple pizza too!" wow you are so original and funny. i would rather see what people really think even if its some bullshit, at least its hones.

I don't engage in coomerposting but I personally enjoy seeing others get off to my works, and I'm mildly annoyed at e621 for depriving me of the amusement all these years. On Furaffinity you had the option of putting the "Creepy Comments Welcome" banner on your page to let people know they could be horny on your posts, but I guess that wouldn't work so well on an imageboard. Maybe there could be a hornypost checkbox when writing comments and then users could hide them all in their account settings if they want.

kinkock said:
Wait, so floofgens is implementing the same badly disclosed controversial aggressive policy against coomerposters that e621 has where literal jokes can get you banned? damn.

I mean... they are the same staff, but now even more powerful since they are not bound to a superior entity (that wasn't THAT involved to begin with, but still) so...

xruyi said:
like when you comment horny shit like "i wish i was the chair..." and get banned? why is it forbidden there? this sometimes produces funniest shit and if not it still harms no one

I agree, I like those types of comments. Sure, very creep and unhinged things, especially on safe works, should be discouraged and fought against, but they set the bar way too low.

anonymless said:
I don't engage in coomerposting but I personally enjoy seeing others get off to my works, and I'm mildly annoyed at e621 for depriving me of the amusement all these years. On Furaffinity you had the option of putting the "Creepy Comments Welcome" banner on your page to let people know they could be horny on your posts, but I guess that wouldn't work so well on an imageboard. Maybe there could be a hornypost checkbox when writing comments and then users could hide them all in their account settings if they want.

FA's way is pretty good, I think it should be in the hands of the artist, on Pawbooru mods are open to coomerposts and even point people around to it, or treat coomerposts as requests.

FA doesn't let you upload others work in the same way boorus do though. Maybe something like DNP ruling by artist, and have that kind of flag on the top of s/q/e posts.

That would take more to code up and get everyones preferences though so I see the reason why there's just a default. So my only issues is Blep's defaults are leftovers from E6ai, which came from E621.

xruyi said:
DNC

Do Not Cooment? :P - DNC makes me think no-comments allowed but would be funny if it were something else

enkin said:
These restrictive commenting rules are from when e6ai was setting everything to be a copypaste from e6ai so they can easily just not apply anymore.
And I think they were the same as e621 so top down from Bad Dragon. (yep word for word) https://e621.net/help/inappropriate_comments

Most boorus aren't nearly trying to be as 'clean facing' while hosting raunchy content. Personally downvotes exist already for people who want to shadowban these comments if the coom-munity doesn't like em we don't need extra moderation wasted on it.

wow, i dont think those rules have been strictly enforced in a hot decade on e621?
and while i rarely comment like that myself, I also think a lot of that seems silly to discourage.

all i can agree with is obviously going nsfw on sfw content, the "wish what would happen" stuff mostly, especially if it moves way out of the theme and the range of the person posting the picture, its essentially just backdoor begging,
and the 'wish it was x instead of what you posted' since its also backdoor begging and somewhat insulting.

everything else, while possibly very cringe, should be allowed or ignored. since there's not gonna be a lot of deep thought under any post, there might as well not be comments otherwise

Updated

lewt said:
wow, i dont think those rules have been strictly enforced in a hot decade on e621?
and while i rarely comment like that myself, I also think a lot of that seems silly to discourage.
...
everything else, while possibly very cringe, should be allowed or ignored. since there's not gonna be a lot of deep thought under any post, there might as well not be comments otherwise

Yeah, I think comments should be liberated too. I don't mind them at all, and it could be simple to add the ability to disable comments completely if you're a user, in a future Blep update. (Or just use "Block Element," which might be part of a person's browser adblock.)

For me, I don't mind what another person says, unless I don't want to hear what anyone says. So that means I want people to be free to comment under more fair and liberated guidelines, and also, I want to be able to fully disable reading comments if I choose. E621 went too far with their intense crackdown on comments, and so I think Blep has a chance to fix this.

enkin said:
These restrictive commenting rules are from when e6ai was setting everything to be a copypaste from e6ai so they can easily just not apply anymore.
And I think they were the same as e621 so top down from Bad Dragon. (yep word for word) https://e621.net/help/inappropriate_comments

Doesn't matter if they're copied over or from whence they came. They're still the current rules for blep.art unless and until MakeFox decides to change them. Which is at MakeFox's sole discretion. What other boorus do or don't do has no bearing on what MakeFox decides to do with blep.art.

lewt said:
wow, i dont think those rules have been strictly enforced in a hot decade on e621?

e621 moderation is very oppressive, I've seen someone comment on one of my commissions that got uploaded there get a red mark/flag/warning from the mods for saying "I think X is hot, but there's no tag for it"

Ultimately everyone's experience will be different, what probably matters most is if someone's targeting you and reporting your comments.