Topic: Replace "gynomorph" and "andromorph" with dickgirl and cuntboy respectively

Posted under Site Bug Reports & Feature Requests

Now that we are seperate from e621 and bad dragon, I think it is time to correct this controversial "gynomorph" and "andromorph" crap as those words were never good replacements for dickgirl and cuntboy anyway due to meaning different things

kinkock said:
Now that we are seperate from e621 and bad dragon, I think it is time to correct this controversial "gynomorph" and "andromorph" crap as those words were never good replacements for dickgirl and cuntboy anyway due to meaning different things

I'm unaware of any controversy about this, save people's preferences for a particular tag out of habit. Gynomorph and andromorph are perfectly cromulent words that accurately describe some forms of intersex anatomy. Altering these would also have huge knock on effects on aliases and implications which would require a lot of cleanup.

94 different tags are aliased to gynomorph, dickgirl included. If you prefer the term dickgirl then search and tag using it. It makes no difference on the user's end save which tag appears in the tag list on a post. That's the point of aliases is to let people search and tag how they want without needing to know know 94 different tags and fragmenting results for everyone.

The same is true of andromorph with the 41 tags aliased to it.

But on a personal note, I inherently dislike tags like dickgirl and cuntboy because they inherently ascribe an age and gender upon a character that may not be accurate. Tags should be neutral and unambiguous. "Girl" in dickgirl implies a young age, which may not be true. It also ascribes a feminine gender which may not match the character's lore. Likewise with cuntboy, just inverted.

Gynomorph and andromorph are exact and refer only to specific, objective sexual characteristics; they do not imply anything about gender or age, and are thus preferable terms.

Not to mention that cunt is considered by many a misogynistic slur.

I am very sure the controversy arose from E621 forcing politically correctness on the userbase over being "offended" at the terms that were used to describe these bodies like cuntboy, dickgirl since the beginning even outside of the furry fandom. Aliasing to it doesn't make a difference, because the social justice crusade is the default.

Girl doesn't really ascribe age either the way boorus host them, they're ancient terminology like 1girl, furry girl, ect. To just speedrun searching instead of typing "female solo"

I was not the biggest fan of the terms cuntboy and dickgirl, but I gotta say replacing them with andromorph and gynomorph is even worse. I can't even remember which one is which without looking them up, and I've never seen either of them used outside of e621 (and its derivatives like this one).

Technically, the political correctness framing is actually the original framing. Dickboy/cuntgirl users are operating from a position of "That's how we've always done it," even though the terminology is rough and memey. That's the politic.

So in other words, the Reality Correct words are gynomorph and andromorph, but the Politically Correct words(the words that appeal to entrenched culture/power,) are cuntboy and dickgirl. Even more Reality Correct could be transgender_girl and transgender_man, because that's what those abstract porn ideas actually are in true real life reality. I don't wish to advocate for things that make it harder to accurately tag images for the sake of art-viewing, so some level of leeway is fine, but even then, I don't think dickgirl/cuntboy are ideal for reasons already mentioned.

I like this change idea.
I've never heard the words gynomorph and andromorph outside this chain of sites (I've heard androgynous before, is it related?). Even tho I used the tag a couple of times, I still have to recap the meaning of them before using to remember.
Cuntboy and dickgirl are very easy to remember and practically self explanatory to anyone.

cocoa_morsel said:
But on a personal note, I inherently dislike tags like dickgirl and cuntboy because they inherently ascribe an age and gender upon a character that may not be accurate. Tags should be neutral and unambiguous. "Girl" in dickgirl implies a young age, which may not be true. It also ascribes a feminine gender which may not match the character's lore. Likewise with cuntboy, just inverted.

What? I don't think anyone would think 'dickgirl can't be used on a grown woman because it has 'girl' in the name'. And they sound better than dickwoman and cuntman.
Also, those are not lore tags, it doesn't matter if they match the lore or not, they are tagged as such because it is what the image looks like.

cocoa_morsel said:
Not to mention that cunt is considered by many a misogynistic slur.

Toughen up, I suppose. It is not like we are addressing real-life people or anything, unlike real-life porn sites that use this and many other words to refer to real life humans.

In fact, many tags should have a tweek in them, like 'overweight', it should just be 'fat', since overweight sounds more like a medical condition rather than a physical characteristic.

xruyi said:
whats wrong with "futanari"?

Nothing, and that is actually my personally preferred tag, but I'm also willing to admit this is mostly because I have used that tag for over 30 years. But ultimately *something* has to be the singular tag.

romanicyte said:
(I've heard androgynous before, is it related?)

Yes. The root word "andro" is Greek for "man". Gyno being Greek for "woman". Androgyny is the possession of both masculine (andro) and feminine (gyno) characteristics. These are the same andro and gyno in andromorph and gynomorph.

romanicyte said:
What? I don't think anyone would think 'dickgirl can't be used on a grown woman because it has 'girl' in the name'. And they sound better than dickwoman and cuntman.

Funnily enough nearly half the gynomorph aliases are variants of "woman with a penis". And cuntman specifically is aliased to andromorph, which means that enough people were using those tags to justify an alias to begin with. Because seemingly "girl" and "boy" denoted age to enough that some specifically wanted "woman" and "man" tagged not "girl" and "boy".

Andromorph and gynomorph solves this by describing specific appearance only and nothing else. Which is precisely why they are preferable. They don't imply age, gender, lore, anything. They only refer to specific type of appearance. It's just cleaner and unambiguous.

romanicyte said:
Toughen up, I suppose. It is not like we are addressing real-life people or anything, unlike real-life porn sites that use this and many other words to refer to real life humans.

Lol, I didn't say I personally was offended. I run around here with no blacklist at all. I just know that some will not even say the word, and some insist on censoring it as "c*nt". I don't see any reason to purposely switch to a term some find offensive when there's already a perfectly accurate and inoffensive word already in use.

Updated

Blep is a site/community which exists downstream of e621 and has a userbase which will largely expect to use the same tags as e621 uses. We therefore don't plan to change anything about these tags until and unless e621 changes their usage.

This will, in general, be the case for any question of tagging - for consistency and familiarity, we'll almost always be going with "whatever e621 does" unless it's something e621 doesn't handle (e.g. the artist/director thing, which we're still considering).