Topic: I preferred "Director" over "Artist"

Posted under General

autosnep said:

What I propose: add multiple distinct creator tag categories, distinct "director" and "artist".

That being said, it's probably not a perfect solution either. e621 added the "contributor" tag category, and it's a mess. I still don't understand why an animator is an "artist", but a modeler is a "contributor"...

That is unfortunately a potentially much bigger code change and it complicates search for what are honestly vanity reasons. At that point you might as well just got with 'creator' and call it a day.

It's worth keeping in mind that an AI model does not have creative liberty despite the fact that when talking about image and video gen at least, it's making almost all of the small decisions. So it makes sense for it to just be one thing (whether 'artist', 'director', or just 'creator') despite how wrong that might feel. If anything the distinct tag categories should be on contributor tags since those are accessories instead of a high importance tag that is used in lots of places in the codebase that could potentially break things.

what about "collaborator"? it's like a team thing, you gave the idea the and the AI did most of the work but you still contributed, so you collaborated

or even commissioner...because we're basically commissioning art from the computer, wait until AI realizes it could get paid for this 0_0 :P

Updated

Enkin

Member

I do think it's not that great to use Artist: on ai sites, because of duplication and confusion you can have some artists and ai users have the same handle. I already ran into this with an artist on pixiv having the same handle as someone using ai but weren't trying to copy the pixiv artist.

enkin said:
I do think it's not that great to use Artist: on ai sites, because of duplication and confusion you can have some artists and ai users have the same handle. I already ran into this with an artist on pixiv having the same handle as someone using ai but weren't trying to copy the pixiv artist.

Ditto. I've ran into this at least three times so far when downloading pics for my collection.

EMX

Member

enkin said:
I do think it's not that great to use Artist: on ai sites, because of duplication and confusion you can have some artists and ai users have the same handle. I already ran into this with an artist on pixiv having the same handle as someone using ai but weren't trying to copy the pixiv artist.

People with duplicate/overly similar usernames is an issue in general. Sometimes people use generic usernames or two people just get the same idea, even with very specific usernames.

The way to resolve this is to add a _(suffix) to differentiate the two unrelated artists/creators and prevent confusion.

enkin said:
I do think it's not that great to use Artist: on ai sites, because of duplication and confusion you can have some artists and ai users have the same handle. I already ran into this with an artist on pixiv having the same handle as someone using ai but weren't trying to copy the pixiv artist.

So what though? It can be a problem only on a site that hosts both AI and manual art.
The same handle can happen (and does happen) even between two common art sites, like furaffinity and deviantart, for example, ai or no ai.