Topic: Changes to blep.art Moderation

Posted under General

If I may offer some personal feedback:

New moderator team = new opportunities

I strongly disliked moderation practices where admins ban people or lock threads simply because someone disagrees or starts an argument, even when there are no insults or disrespect involved. Frankly, I hated this on e6ai, and I've already noticed that you've blocked someone who tried to argue their point here. I genuinely ask you to reconsider this approach. Nothing discourages community participation more than feeling that disagreements and differing opinions are not welcome. Even if you had good reasons to block that person, you should consider how such decisions are perceived by the rest of the community.

The e6ai's moderation team had serious "god syndrome" issues. Their attitude often seemed to be: "I know better, I have the power, so shut up or else." This created a significant communication obstacle between the users and the moderation team and drove many people away from the site.

Regarding upload rules:

I've always agreed that having quality standards is a good idea. However, the practical interpretation and enforcement of those standards on the e6ai site were seriously flawed.

I'm disappointed to hear that changes to the upload rules are already considered out of the question. I'd like to know whether we can have a calm, constructive discussion about this here.

In my opinion, there's a Grand Canyon-sized gap between e6ai's restrictive upload policy and simply allowing people to spam poor-quality content. There's plenty of room for reasonable adjustments that could benefit many users without hurting anyone, except perhaps a handful of people who cannot tolerate even the slightest AI imperfections, which seems to be a common allergy among moderation staff - perfectly natural and understandable, of course. However, it creates the false impression that the majority of users share the same intolerance.
.
Creating AI art takes time, effort, and often money. When someone invests all that into creating something and then shares it for free, having their work deleted can be incredibly discouraging. The old system had several problems:

- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost. Comments and favs were lost too if the upload remained deleted. Tags, descriptions - things uploader could've spent 20 minutes on.

- Content could be deleted even when the overwhelming majority of users would consider it a valuable, high-quality upload. Quality is more than a checklist of technical imperfections. Focusing on something like a potentially extra claw visible under magnification glass while ignoring everything else that makes a piece of art good is fundamentally misguided.

- Not everyone minds AI imperfections. Good models are expensive, and users should have a choice. One possible solution would be a "not_perfect" tag. Anyone who cannot tolerate seeing a hand briefly changing from five fingers to four in a two-minute video could simply blacklist that tag. Uploaders who fail to use it when appropriate could face some form of penalty to prevent abuse of the system.


A concern: creator's control over uploaded content.

This site appears to have copied everything, and I see that as a potential problem.

Once the e6ai disappears, creators might lose the ability to remove their original uploads. This could become particularly problematic if someone later decides to move to another platform where content already available elsewhere cannot be used. Creators should retain control over their work and where it is published.


Finally, I sincerely wish the new team all the best.

I'm keeping my fingers crossed that the new staff will prove to be much more approachable, friendly, and helpful than the team on E6ai. A more open-minded approach to moderation and community feedback would surely attract more uploaders and bring the platform much more good content.

"Just one more thing..."

sijah said:
You underestimate the number of people that refuse to use Discord.

Couldn't agree more.
I simply don't want to share my real phone number on platforms associated with things that are so widely stigmatized by the general public - the furry art. Discord requires a phone number, and that's a deal-breaker for me.

Please make the most of the opportunity that having a forum here provides. This is exactly where people should be sharing their experiences with AI prompting, exchanging ideas, and discussing various topics. Please don't fragment the community or push people towards corporate-controlled platforms like Discord.

Updated

You can't get more pointless and bitchy drama than in a furry community. Goddamn the E6AI crew are acting like such babies.

+1 to not using Discord for porn websites. I don't shit where I sleep. My wife and kids have access to my computer and my Discord is squeaky clean.

pat_furring said:
If I may offer some personal feedback:

New moderator team = new opportunities

I strongly disliked moderation practices where admins ban people or lock threads simply because someone disagrees or starts an argument...
I've always agreed that having quality standards is a good idea. ...
Please don't fragment the community or push people towards corporate-controlled platforms like Discord.

Yeah, I agree with a lot of pat's post. I think the old mods had expectations of power, rather than a desire to help, and that sort of thing is the seed of corruption. They expect to have power over others, and that's no good! Do to them what they have done to others, and watch them get so mad about it! And look at what happened here. I also think that they were forcing their beliefs on the rest of us, in regards to art freedom. Or was it their funding source?

Whatever has been going on with that dragon company, I think that's separate from us here, and that separation is something that MakeFox should embrace.

So I think pat furring here has a lot of good ideas. When it comes to Discord, I think there's been a big vibe-shift on the internet as far as that entire thing goes. It's called enshittification, and it can happen to e621, it can happen to reddit, it can happen to telegram or discord, and it could happen to YOU! And those who are wise preemptively avoid platforms that are likely to enshittify. That's why I'm recommending Armada again. I think it's better than stoat, because I've known about stoat for a long time, and it didn't get my attention the way Armada/Nostr does. Try it out and you'll see that it's easier and better in every way.

Updated

pat_furring said:

Regarding upload rules:

For uploads, I agree. I believe the rules needs to be loosen a little, not a lot just a little bit. I was getting tired of having my posts deleted for very small unnoticeable errors, it was very disheartening and rarely posted because of it. They're way to strict.

pat_furring said:
Once the e6ai disappears, creators might lose the ability to remove their original uploads. This could become particularly problematic if someone later decides to move to another platform where content already available elsewhere cannot be used. Creators should retain control over their work and where it is published.

Uh.... as someone that works for/with a RL publisher handling written-word authors and copyright law, that's not how the world works, or copyright law. Once you publish it, it's completely out of your hands unless someone literally copies it (illegal duplication) claiming it's theirs, or uses it _commercially_ in a manner outside of fair use exceptions (mockery/parody, analysis, education, etc.).

Once you put it out, it is no longer yours to control. That's usually the part of ever TOS for every public-contribution website since the very early days of the internet - that the ownership of the site has the right to display, distribute, alter, remove, restrict, or otherwise edit any work presented to them.

Just saying... for whatever it's worth.

pat_furring said:
strongly disliked moderation practices where admins ban people or lock threads simply because someone disagrees or starts an argument, even when there are no insults or disrespect involved. Frankly, I hated this on e6ai, and I've already noticed that you've blocked someone who tried to argue their point here. I genuinely ask you to reconsider this approach. Nothing discourages community participation more than feeling that disagreements and differing opinions are not welcome. Even if you had good reasons to block that person, you should consider how such decisions are perceived by the rest of the community.

So far the only posts I've deleted are ones that have gone completely off the rails, or been so incredibly crazy off topic or intentionally inflammatory and argumentative with no hope of a civil discussion at all. The one account banned in that thread was banned for abusive posts after a warning to keep it civil, not for disagreeing.

I value civil discourse and free and open speech. While we're still discussing how our policies on these matters will be laid out, I hope our entire team will agree that it serves no purpose to stifle the free expression of opinion.

hinoserm said:
So far the only posts I've deleted are ones that have gone completely off the rails, or been so incredibly crazy off topic or intentionally inflammatory and argumentative with no hope of a civil discussion at all. The one account banned in that thread was banned for abusive posts after a warning to keep it civil, not for disagreeing.

I value civil discourse and free and open speech. While we're still discussing how our policies on these matters will be laid out, I hope our entire team will agree that it serves no purpose to stifle the free expression of opinion.

I wholly concur... Ars Gratia Artis and Jeffersonian government ("He who governs best, governs least")... Let people work through manure themselves. No one will be satisfied, people will enjoy the slinging, and everyone learns something. So long as it doesn't threaten the governing/corporate body, that is. Ejection of terrorists/anarchists is always agreeable to sane adults.

hinoserm said:
So far the only posts I've deleted are ones that have gone completely off the rails, or been so incredibly crazy off topic or intentionally inflammatory and argumentative with no hope of a civil discussion at all. The one account banned in that thread was banned for abusive posts after a warning to keep it civil, not for disagreeing.

I value civil discourse and free and open speech. While we're still discussing how our policies on these matters will be laid out, I hope our entire team will agree that it serves no purpose to stifle the free expression of opinion.

As a bystander, I'll just confirm that this is what happened here; I saw the posts that were deleted/banned, and I would have done the same. Nothing unreasonable has happened here so far, and that's why I'm still here. I'm just hoping for freedom, now and forever!

pat_furring said:
d often money. When someone invests all that into creating something and then shares it for free, having their work deleted can be incredibly discouraging. The old system had several problems:

- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost. Comments and favs were lost too if the upload remained deleted. Tags, descriptions - things uploader could've spent 20 minutes on.

i want to request as part of new functionality, since this site is getting rewritten anyway, to change from deleting instantly to hiding if the post does not meet quality requirements. i had several times lost a picture that i liked because apparently there was some bad finger anatomy in background that i would never notice in a thousand years if not for deletion reason telling me about it.

instead of deleting instantly, just hide it from main page, but not from the post itself if you have the link, so people like me can save it. i still remember that one liwih uplaod with rainbow dash in a wedding dress that i want to see again and it was deleted! where is my rainbow dash wife. or was it applejack, i'm not sure. it got me hard anyway. wtf upload it back.

I think a vote based approving system could work good and reduce workload on mods. If a post gets enough up votes in whatever time period it gets approved, if it doesn't it can still be manually approved and if it gets enough down votes or flagged for something it can trigger a high priority manual review request.

firewolf890 said:
I think a vote based approving system could work good and reduce workload on mods. If a post gets enough up votes in whatever time period it gets approved, if it doesn't it can still be manually approved and if it gets enough down votes or flagged for something it can trigger a high priority manual review request.

That's a good way for peripheral-interest matters to get buried under the manure pile of populism, and as such I can't endorse it.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
That's a good way for peripheral-interest matters to get buried under the manure pile of populism, and as such I can't endorse it.

Now if that was revised to positive-approval by vote and otherwise going to moderator evaluation, I could endorse it without any hesitation.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
That's a good way for peripheral-interest matters to get buried under the manure pile of populism, and as such I can't endorse it.

Just keep the daily upload limit small and the ability for anyone to flag a manual review for quality/spam posting.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
Now if that was revised to positive-approval by vote and otherwise going to moderator evaluation, I could endorse it without any hesitation.

Isn't that what I said?

I am bummed that the old staff had to experience a sort of "monkey's paw" rescue of the website.
But, I'm also a realist, and I consider their expectations to be rather untethered from how things in life work.

I wish that life worked in a way that always just made things flow. But, it never really does, and "going with the flow" requires a bit of sacrifice of what you desire.

In essence, I get where the old staff were coming from, but believe they should have been ready to "play ball" for at least a little while until their relationship with MakeFox could develop, at which point they could request certain changes or certain things to stay the same. Feelings are just feelings, and everyone has them, and you just can't expect the world to bend itself to suit them.

No one would find it reasonable if the employees of a Starbucks suddenly thought they owned the place because their location got sold and became a Dutch Bros.

Ultimately, I hope MakeFox can keep this site around, and I also hope the old staff can find another site for themselves some day (if there's no chance at reconciliation here).
The old staff still have their Discord and a passionate community.
So, live and let live, I say... and that's always what I'll say.

tamara said:
- MakeFox thought that hosting the site gave them ownership of everything and power to do whatever they wanted.

This is quite literally exactly what that means, and it is exactly the same power Bad Dragon had over e6AI (which they unilaterally executed to delete e6AI). MakeFox owns the right of management for every aspect on their website. You can make your own clone, at which point you will own the right of management for every aspect of your site. That is how hosting works.

Jello was just operating under a delusion that community volunteers are entitled to ownership of a non-profit organization's domain, infrastructure, and operations, simply because that non-profit organization cloned the website for them. So MakeFox executed their ownership over their domain, infrastructure, and operations to remove the party demanding the rights to a hostile takeover of MakeFox's property. (Exaggerating here to mirror e6AI's rhetoric against MakeFox.)

Updated

haruinfigaru said:
This is quite literally exactly what that means, and it is exactly the same power Bad Dragon had over e6AI (which they unilaterally executed to delete e6AI). MakeFox owns the right of management for every aspect on their website. You can make your own clone, at which point you will own the right of management for every aspect of your site. That is how hosting works.

Jello was just operating under a delusion that community volunteers are entitled to ownership of a non-profit organization's domain, infrastructure, and operations, simply because that non-profit organization cloned the website for them. So MakeFox executed their ownership over their domain, infrastructure, and operations to remove the party demanding the rights to a hostile takeover of MakeFox's property. (Exaggerating here to mirror Jelloponies' rhetoric against MakeFox.)

*passes haruinfigaru a manure fork for the rhetoric* Agree, but let's not add to the manure pile. Plenty of crap going around right now anyway. But, yeah, really... duh. Corporate ownership is corporate ownership, whether they leave things up to you or take the reins themselves that _is_ their right.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
You included the negative side of nuking something, not positive-only.

No I said enough negative votes would trigger a high priority manual review request. Pretty much the same as what you said going to moderator evaluation. I never said anything about something getting removed, deleted, or "nuking" just that it would make it higher priority to get evaluated.

firewolf890 said:
No I said enough negative votes would trigger a high priority manual review request. Pretty much the same as what you said going to moderator evaluation. I never said anything about something getting removed, deleted, or "nuking" just that it would make it higher priority to get evaluated.

Ok, must have misread or misinterpeted. One of the perils of multitasking. Please accept my apologies. I'm trying to juggle this manure pile of 'fun' along with some other things (including saving a segment of what's left of e6ai before it disappears), including actual paying work.

pat_furring said:

[snip]

- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost. Comments and favs were lost too if the upload remained deleted. Tags, descriptions - things uploader could've spent 20 minutes on.

[snip]

- Not everyone minds AI imperfections. Good models are expensive, and users should have a choice. One possible solution would be a "not_perfect" tag. Anyone who cannot tolerate seeing a hand briefly changing from five fingers to four in a two-minute video could simply blacklist that tag. Uploaders who fail to use it when appropriate could face some form of penalty to prevent abuse of the system.

I don't have much of an opinion on the stuff about the mods; my experience with them (although short, since I only started uploading ~2 months ago) wasn't negative. I had a few images that were taken down for small errors, and that went back up when I sent the corrected versions to make the replacement. They were errors that were small enough for me to go "wow, I really didn't notice that when fixing a few other things", but I'm still glad that they were pointed out and that I could fix them.

It IS a shame that the images get straight up deleted and lose the chance of getting that initial boost of visibility in the homepage. The only way to get the "full attention" would be to upload the new version as a new post, but then you would lose the votes/favourites/comments from the original upload. To me personally, it wasn't a huge issue, but I preferred to replace the "taken down" version so the users that fave'd that one wouldn't lose the image in their list.

All that to say that I agree with the idea of having a "not_perfect" tag so users can filter those out. I'd also suggest a way to let the uploader know if that tag gets added to pics they upload, if that's possible.

For example, adding that tag also lets the person adding to fill out the reason, and that gets sent to uploader as a DMail. If the uploader is also the creator of the image, they can then correct it, ask for a replacement and then remove the "not_perfect" tag. If they're not the creator, then the image just keeps the tag and is filtered out by people that add it to their blacklist.

This could probably be abused, to spam someone with fake reasons or just to put their images on the "blacklist" of several users, so it needs to be looked into better, but I just wanted to give a general idea.

About the "Uploaders who fail to use it when appropriate could face some form of penalty to prevent abuse of the system." part, maybe that's a bit too rough, since someone might upload an image with an error that simply wasn't noticed (speaking from experience ^^' ). That could feel a bit like getting punished for an honest and basically harmless error.

My biggest nitpick is the mods' issues with various borderline rules. I noticed one image that I'd archived was nuked for "young" reasons. It was a literal cat and a literal mouse. Feral. As though a mouse exists that would be the size of a housecat...

That's just the most recent/easiest example of moderation overreach/abject stupidity. The person tried to correct it by making it anthro - nuked. Gave the mouse boobs - nuked. Bigger boobs. Nuked. They gave up.

kaltingale said:
-Jello personally downplays it as "MakeFox just trying to cater to a few known troublemakers" and refuses to acknowledge that some people felt mistreated and instead presents his team as "always fair", even though it's a very ignorant and egoistical thing to say when there are quite a few people saying otherwise

What made me twitch was when Sergalbutt said in reference to someone questioning a possible easing on the quality or young content moderation:
https://blep.art/forum_posts/6615

Sergalbutt said:
Our quality guidelines are what makes us who we are, and in itself was an appealing aspect for those for gave us this new home. (and obviously for the userbase we've had all along!)

And my immediate thought was, "you mean the userbase you had left after you banned, beat down, or ran off everyone whoever disagreed or questioned your methods?" Before he locked the thread shortly after because discussion of changes he/they don't like aren't (weren't) allowed.

sijah said:
What made me twitch was when Sergalbutt said in reference to someone questioning a possible easing on the quality or young content moderation:
https://blep.art/forum_posts/6615
And my immediate thought was, "you mean the userbase you had left after you banned, beat down, or ran off everyone whoever disagreed or questioned your methods?" Before he locked the thread shortly after because discussion of changes he/they don't like aren't (weren't) allowed.

Oh, don't forget the one South American gent that had a scribble signature that they kept nuking for "attempted signature". They went back and nuked everything because they couldn't realize it was the same scribble in EVERY IMAGE. Petty pissery...

Then there was a number of reasonable images that were nuked for being "mistaken for a photograph" when anyone having a functioning prefrontal cortex, the observational skills of a near-sighted ferret, and the anatomical knowledge of a 3rd grader would know that it couldn't be a photograph, or real.

But... they're there. We're here. We'll see what the new guys do. Hopefully they'll take a cue from the more reasoned complaints.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
My biggest nitpick is the mods' issues with various borderline rules. I noticed one image that I'd archived was nuked for "young" reasons. It was a literal cat and a literal mouse. Feral. As though a mouse exists that would be the size of a housecat...

That's just the most recent/easiest example of moderation overreach/abject stupidity. The person tried to correct it by making it anthro - nuked. Gave the mouse boobs - nuked. Bigger boobs. Nuked. They gave up.

You see these types of comments again and again. From different people, from different times and different situations. All of them describing how the users were faced with unfair treatment and even attempting to fix things amounts to nothing in many of these cases. And yet, Jello comes out and says "We always treated everyone fairly". If that doesn't show you what kind of person he and his team are, I don't know what else to tell you.

One of the users got their submission deleted for "3 vs 4 toes". They showed the mod team a half transparent layer where it was clearly visible that one toe is simply obstructed by the character's foot. The janitor disregarded it and said that this is still a "3 vs 4 toes situation" and kept the submission deleted. That's far from the only time this kind of situation happened where staff failed to acknowledge how perspectives work and that the object not being visible doesn't mean it doesn't exist. That makes me think it was either an excuse to powertrip and frustrate the users, or the staff seriously lacks any fundamental understanding of art basics.

And don't even get me started on how one of the submissions got deleted for "poor anus details" on a fully inpainted and edited image. The anus looked like any other you see in furry art. There was objectively nothing wrong with it. What else this could be if not an attempt to attack the creator and discourage them from posting?

kaltingale said:
You see these types of comments again and again. From different people, from different times and different situations. All of them describing how the users were faced with unfair treatment and even attempting to fix things amounts to nothing in many of these cases. And yet, Jello comes out and says "We always treated everyone fairly". If that doesn't show you what kind of person he and his team are, I don't know what else to tell you.

One of the users got their submission deleted for "3 vs 4 toes". They showed the mod team a half transparent layer where it was clearly visible that one toe is simply obstructed by the character's foot. The janitor disregarded it and said that this is still a "3 vs 4 toes situation" and kept the submission deleted. That's far from the only time this kind of situation happened where staff failed to acknowledge how perspectives work and that the object not being visible doesn't mean it doesn't exist. That makes me think it was either an excuse to powertrip and frustrate the users, or the staff seriously lacks any fundamental understanding of art basics.

And don't even get me started on how one of the submissions got deleted for "poor anus details" on a fully inpainted and edited image. The anus looked like any other you see in furry art. There was objectively nothing wrong with it. What else this could be if not an attempt to attack the creator and discourage them from posting?

As I'm reading this, this song is what's rolling through my playlist... (Let's see if this gets me censured)...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mcy71uJv3lQ

But yeah, not exactly welcoming. And trust me, I've seen every kind of smut there is (and a lot that shouldn't be) as I ran a porn site in the 1990s. There's a whole lot of stuff _I_ don't like here and there, but I'm not about to be petty enough to crap on it just because it's not my preference, or so far from anatomically possible it hurts.

Equally, they'll ding something for being 'too something' but equally will nuke another imagine for being 'too realistic'. Picking a logical position seemed to be ananthema there. Hopefully here will be better when criteria changes start happening.

My condolences to the new admins who had to be dropped into such a hot mess. Stay strong. We have faith in you.

sijah said:
What made me twitch was when Sergalbutt said in reference to someone questioning a possible easing on the quality or young content moderation:
https://blep.art/forum_posts/6615
And my immediate thought was, "you mean the userbase you had left after you banned, beat down, or ran off everyone whoever disagreed or questioned your methods?" Before he locked the thread shortly after because discussion of changes he/they don't like aren't (weren't) allowed.

I personally find this argument about "alienating a large portion of the userbase" to be funny. The young tag is blacklisted by default, you can't see even SFW images unless you manually go and turn the blacklist off, forcing yourself to see the type of stuff you don't like. How is that alienating anyone? And isn't banning certain types of content the literal definition of alienating a portion of the community? Which also leads to other issues like the staff being incredibly subjective and often having different opinions on what makes a character "young" and should be a reason for a deletion. And I'm not going to take the "some people just believe this kink to be disturbing and wouldn't want to use a platform hosting it" as a valid argument. That's just a load of BS. Are they meaning to tell me that "young" content specifically is enough for them to quit, but at the same time they are totally fine with gore, vore, noncon, incest, feral and realistic feral? Things aren't adding up and only looks like perfomative outrage. "Use the blacklist and don't invade the space you have an issue" with is the most based rule one can have on the platform that hosts any kind of content that isn't just "male/female, missionary, married couple". Just to make things clear, I'm not arguing with you, but expanding on your post.

haruinfigaru said:
MakeFox owns the right of management for every aspect on their website. You can make your own clone, at which point you will own the right of management for every aspect of your site. That is how hosting works.

No, it's not. Where have you seen hosting work that way ? O_o

I can get a website hosted by Wordpress, for example. They provide the infrastructure to run my website, but the fact that they host it gives them no rights to decide who should run my site, or how to run it, or even ownership of it's contents. Hosting doesn't mean managing, never has been.

haruinfigaru said:
Jello was just operating under a delusion that community volunteers are entitled to ownership of a non-profit organization's domain, infrastructure, and operations, simply because that non-profit organization cloned the website for them. So MakeFox executed their ownership over their domain, infrastructure, and operations to remove the party demanding the rights to a hostile takeover of MakeFox's property. (Exaggerating here to mirror e6AI's rhetoric against MakeFox.)

Have you read the contract that MakeFox sent to the e6ai team ? It's on e6ai discord, if you're curious. It is a quite enlightening read, and shares a new light on what MakeFox says here : https://blep.art/Blep-Receipts.html It's also interesting that said contract wasn't published as well on that 'receipts' page.

kaltingale said:
I personally find this argument about "alienating a large portion of the userbase" to be funny. The young tag is blacklisted by default, you can't see even SFW images unless you manually go and turn the blacklist off, forcing yourself to see the type of stuff you don't like. How is that alienating anyone? And isn't banning certain types of content the literal definition of alienating a portion of the community? Which also leads to other issues like the staff being incredibly subjective and often having different opinions on what makes a character "young" and should be a reason for a deletion. And I'm not going to take the "some people just believe this kink to be disturbing and wouldn't want to use a platform hosting it" as a valid argument. That's just a load of BS. Are they meaning to tell me that "young" content specifically is enough for them to quit, but at the same time they are totally fine with gore, vore, noncon, incest, feral and realistic feral? Things aren't adding up and only looks like perfomative outrage. "Use the blacklist and don't invade the space you have an issue" with is the most based rule one can have on the platform that hosts any kind of content that isn't just "male/female, missionary, married couple". Just to make things clear, I'm not arguing with you, but expanding on your post.

don't forget the scat fetish and nippledick things.

tamara said:
No, it's not. Where have you seen hosting work that way ? O_o

I can get a website hosted by Wordpress, for example. They provide the infrastructure to run my website, but the fact that they host it gives them no rights to decide who should run my site, or how to run it, or even ownership of it's contents. Hosting doesn't mean managing, never has been.

Have you read the contract that MakeFox sent to the e6ai team ? It's on e6ai discord, if you're curious. It is a quite enlightening read, and shares a new light on what MakeFox says here : https://blep.art/Blep-Receipts.html It's also interesting that said contract wasn't published as well on that 'receipts' page.

Please tell me who in their right mind would pay to host a site that will not generate money for them.

If you get a site hosted by Wordpress, you either compensate them directly by paying a fee, or you compensate them indirectly by them owning your work-product (like submitting things to e6). What would have been the theoretical compensation to MakeFox under your scenario?

da_reel_digitaltf said:
Please tell me who in their right mind would pay to host a site that will not generate money for them.

Bad Dragon does. E621 and e6ai generate absolutely no money for them, and are instead a huge money sinks.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
If you get a site hosted by Wordpress, you either compensate them directly by paying a fee, or you compensate them indirectly by them owning your work-product (like submitting things to e6). What would have been the theoretical compensation to MakeFox under your scenario?

That question is silly since I'm quite sure that no one at MakeFox expected any kind of monetary compensation for taking in a furry imageboard / booru home. They knew what they were getting from the moment contact was established between them and the team of e6ai.

tamara said:
Bad Dragon does. E621 and e6ai generate absolutely no money for them, and are instead a huge money sinks.

That question is silly since I'm quite sure that no one at MakeFox expected any kind of monetary compensation for taking in a furry imageboard / booru home. They knew what they were getting from the moment contact was established between them and the team of e6ai.

No they don't. It's the advertising arm of the sextoy shop. It's cheaper for them to attract the eyeballs to their own spaces than to pay for the same coverage by Google Ads.

hinoserm said:
We're all sleep deprived and overworked at this time, please give us some patience to work through everything.

...

I'll own that I made mistakes in how I handled the situation. I underestimated how much an unannounced change would worry a team that had just been through a shutdown, and overlooked the emotional consequences of my decisions.

I also reacted harshly to what was, in hindsight, a simple request, likely due to my own stress and heightened emotions from the rush to get the site up and ready.

My best advice is to separate your technical people from the public relations people. Working with machines and working with people are two different kinds of hell, and they don't mix well. Definitely don't task yourself with doing both at once!

Have someone working on the code only, and someone working on the forums only. Don't let one person touch the other. It'll save you a lot of nerves.

ollie_ai said:
I don't have much of an opinion on the stuff about the mods; my experience with them (although short, since I only started uploading ~2 months ago) wasn't negative. I had a few images that were taken down for small errors, and that went back up when I sent the corrected versions to make the replacement. They were errors that were small enough for me to go "wow, I really didn't notice that when fixing a few other things", but I'm still glad that they were pointed out and that I could fix them.

What really dingled my berries about E6AI is that it would deliberately exclude pictures from artists I liked and wanted to see because of some error I don't even care about. I have plenty of AI and hand-drawn pictures of my PC that are far, far from perfect. It's fine. Things don't have to be perfect to be good.

What do you mean the picture I favorited two months ago has been deleted for "low quality"?

Hate the idea of good art going missing.

I'd like to note that the contract would have allowed MakeFox to remove the previous moderation team from their roles via unilateral authority with no path of recourse, along with other non-negotiable stipulations, including the ability to updates to the site's code base. Hinoserm included--as part of the name-change PR--a removal of the takedown form. It is unclear if this was accidental or an attempt to make a change and hoping it wouldn't be noticed.

The previous moderation team, if they had signed the contract, would have had virtually no actual control over anything, including content moderation.

The contract in full is available on e6ai's Discord server, but here are the salient points.

2. Final authority
• The Company has final say on all matters affecting the site. That includes content
policy
, legal compliance, privacy, security, infrastructure and software.
• The Company delegates day-to-day moderation to the Volunteers (section 3). It can
review, amend or revoke that delegation at any time.

5. Company obligations
• Notice of changes. The Company posts planned user-facing or volunteer-facing
changes in the notice channel before they ship. Urgent security and legal fixes may
ship first and be posted right after.

8. Technical review
• Volunteer developers may review code, suggest changes and contribute through the
repository.
• Their review is advisory. It cannot veto or block a Company change.

10. Disputes
• Disputes go first to the two points of contact.
• If they're unresolved, the Company decides.
• If a Volunteer will not accept a Company decision, they may step down. Blocking
implementation is not an option.

That dispute clause is absolutely untenable. At least arbitration has the veneer of neutrality. This clause is basically a giant "fuck you" to the previous moderation team and stinks of bad faith negotiation. "You have a problem? We decide how to resolve it. If you don't like it you can leave. If we don't like it, we can make you leave."

da_reel_digitaltf said:
No they don't. It's the advertising arm of the sextoy shop. It's cheaper for them to attract the eyeballs to their own spaces than to pay for the same coverage by Google Ads.

So, e621 generates no money directly to BD, it only generates traffic through advertisement.

E621 doesn't pay a fee to BD, nor do BD or e621 claim ownership of the artwork submitted to the site, which is generally not even owned by whoever is submitting said art.

Ergo, it's a money sink.

"- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost." <- pat_furring

This is actually something I've faced before, and something I'm looking to handle differently here. I have already contacted one user about a minor issue, and asked if they could fix. They did, I replaced the image, and now it's still up with same tags, likes, etc, just with the minor issue quietly fixed. Problem solved.

If it's a more glaring issue, unfortunately we don't have much plan for that yet, I deleted a picture with an obviously missing finger (gap between two other fingers where one should be) and that one, just re-upload, I think?

We're still working on figuring out how to handle the job left behind for us... But I recommended to the admin group we look into more supportive policies to encourage users, rather than punishing for small issues. I'm open to hearing suggestions too, and we have our telegram group. Suggestions welcome!

knotasysadm said:
Clearly not aware of biases given you try to consult it and then go with it, anyone that sits there and listens to AI and literally uses it for conversation, to abbreviate things and to consult should probably go the same route as Bowen Wan, Sam Nelson, Adam Raine, Christain Faith Madison, etc.

Again, you are very much in the wrong here. You basically just stole what other people worked for, if you want to do the right thing you would build your own website. But instead, what you're doing is stealing one. Which is what I've come to expect from heavy AI users.

This guy's quote would have fallen apart if someone knew about the GitHub open source link (https.://github.com/e621ng/e621ng)(broke the link because I'm not sure if links are allowed here) and also showed them the open source license (the "LICENSE" file from 13 years ago in the repo)

tamara said:
So, e621 generates no money directly to BD, it only generates traffic through advertisement.

E621 doesn't pay a fee to BD, nor do BD or e621 claim ownership of the artwork submitted to the site, which is generally not even owned by whoever is submitting said art.

Ergo, it's a money sink.

From e6AI's own TOS...

"Any User Contributions you post to the Website will be considered non-confidential and non-proprietary.

By posting, submitting, or otherwise providing any User Contributions on the Website, you grant us and our affiliates and service providers, and each of their and our respective licensees, successors and assigns, a worldwide, irrevocable, perpetual, non-exclusive, royalty-free, transferable, sublicensable right and license to freely use, reproduce, distribute, modify, adapt, translate, creative derivative works from, perform, publish, post, broadcast, transmit, and display, and to disclose any and all such User Contributions to third parties, in any and all existing and future formats, media, technologies, and means of delivery, for any purpose. "

Yeah, when you submit stuff to any voluntary-submission site, it becomes theirs to do with as they please under license (as stated here) in perpetuity (as stated here). Don't be naïve about the reality of reality. Without ownership or license of the contributed material, no contributions-based website could exist. Hence the TOS there and here. Duh.

And the e6 string is not a separate legal entity from Dragonfruit. It is a _division_ thereof. It is the advertising arm. The advertising arm for Home Depot is not a separate legal entity. It's entire purpose is to generate sales at Home Depot stores, not to make money from its graphics design department.

I ran a public-submission website in the late 1990s. I know EXACTLY what I'm talking about here.

ollie_ai said: (..) About the (...) penalty (...)" part, maybe that's a bit too rough, since someone might upload an image with an error that simply wasn't noticed (speaking from experience ^^' ). That could feel a bit like getting punished for an honest and basically harmless error.

I didn't mean "ten lashes for every wrong pixel!" ;)) I just meant some reasonable solutions which would not anger the people who prefered the e6ai's approach.

After reading through the responses, I have to admit I'm surprised. Quite a few people took the time to share their opinions about uploads being deleted because of issues they hadn't even noticed, as well as situations where moderation on e6ai caused unnecessary problems and frustration for uploaders.

The site does need to maintain its "high quality" standard, but that standard should exist for the benefit of its users. It shouldn't be about catering to a handful of professional artists and moderators who seem to have developed an allergy to certain things and believe they're acting on behalf of the majority, when in reality they're just a small group among many. The site isn't for artists or moderators. It's for the users, first and foremost.

I think the idea of hiding a post from the public list is a good one. Likewise, the idea of applying a "not_perfect" tag to uploads that are generally good but have some very minor issues, while automatically notifying the uploader is an even better idea.

Please keep in mind that I only wrote down a quick idea. Neither the tagging system nor the "not_perfect" tag name are things I'd consider "great solutions". In fact, I'm sure people smarter than me could come up with something much better.

I'm not entirely convinced about user voting, though. People might downvote something out of spite simply because they dislike the content type or the artist. Making such a system work would require a lot of thought and careful balancing. That said, something close to voting on the upload policy itself could be a good idea

Perhaps a "probation" period? Something like 24-48 hours for a new upload that isn't obviously unacceptable (like a character having human feet in place of hands ;)). During that time, users could vote, but not by "downvoting" or "reporting to manual review". Instead, there could be some kind of upvote threshold.
For example, imagine an upload that's very interesting, has something unique about it, or is exceptionally good/enjoyable to some users in some way, but still has a few flaws. If enough users decide that they like it despite those flaws, it could be allowed to stay. Otherwise, it could be hidden, remaining visible only to people who have favorited or saved it, as well as those who have the direct link.
I'd opt for 48h, because people can upload something and not log in for a few days, thinking they did check everything and there are no flaws so they do not expect any issues.

But most importantly, communication.

"this character has too many fingers" > "Thank you for pointing this out, I can easily fix it" > uploads fixed version > everyone's happy.

But also:

"this character has a problem with ..." -> "yes, I know, but there's no way I could fix it. The model no longer exists or would require 150$ to fix -> "understood, since you can't fix it and the post can be enjoyed by users, we'll leave the tag on it and won't delete the post" -> everyone's happy.

artificialdragon said: My condolences to the new admins who had to be dropped into such a hot mess. Stay strong. We have faith in you.

Supporting each other is important, so I wholeheartedly agree with this message.
I'd also like to apologize about the part of my previous post, which the admin quoted. My intention wasn't to "attack" anyone or accuse anyone of wrongdoing. I simply wanted to voice my concerns. I didn't explain myself very well, and I should have made it clear that I don't know the full story behind the situation. If my wording caused any frustration, I'm sorry.

Updated

Actually, let me repost my thoughts from the original E6AI forum

With regards to Blep.art.

I've read the through what both sides have publicly said, and I gotta be honest - you don't come out looking good.

First - You can't demand a different website owner to hand the keys over to you. Their site, their money, their rules. I understand you want to slot right back into the positions you've had at E6AI - but E6AI is dead and almost buried. You have no privileges on a new site and you can't demand any. You have no authority anymore.

I understand you care about what E6AI was and want to continue in the same way, and want to make sure the new owners don't exploit your free labor and self-destruct the new website out of greed, or carelessness, or out of malice. The new owner admitted he's new to boorus in general, they're making changes out of the blue, everyone's on edge, you want to make sure you're in control of the mess, it's understandable.

As long as you both want what's best for our little community of AI perverts, I think you can talk it out.

Second - Blep have done nothing wrong so far. Stop telling people to spam their forums, delete accounts, withdraw donations, etc. You're just burning bridges with no benefit to anyone.

Is the new owner technically illiterate and wants to turn the new site in a vibecoded mess? Maybe. Who knows. I don't. But it's not the end of the world. A few bugs won't kill anyone. It's fine.

Do they want to change site policies in the way you don't like? Maybe. Reading the recorded conversations, it comes to this:

"We'll try to keep the site and its policies exactly as they were."
"Okay."
"Actually, we have to make a couple of changes."
"We're leaving."

This is an overreaction. They said "try" and that's it. No hard promises. And it wasn't even any kind of big change to anything. Obviously they won't make any hard promises. It's their site. Not yours.

So, staff, please. Sleep it off, gather your thoughts, and try again. I trust you can talk it out like adults. Understand that you're fighting for authority over a new website - and right now you have none. All you can do is convince the new owners you should be part of it.

Updated

pat_furring said:
Supporting each other is important, so I wholeheartedly agree with this message.
I'd also like to apologize if my previous post, which the admin quoted. My intention wasn't to "attack" anyone or accuse anyone of wrongdoing. I simply wanted to voice my concerns. I didn't explain myself very well, and I should have made it clear that I don't know the full story behind the situation. If my wording caused any frustration, I'm sorry.

I'm here because I choose to be here. I'd prefer the database continue without holes in it, though others seem intent on pulling their material... that's life, I suppose. But MakeFox is the group that stepped up to do something. There's another group presumably coming online on Sunday, we'll see if I'm still allowed on the other site to catch a link. I'm picking the side of continuity of materials, really. *chuckles* That's the archivist in me asserting itself.

I offered to help here in whatever way I can, and that offer stands. It's been years since I was 'in the trenches' online, but... I'm here. I have opinions. And I know about corporate reality.

Thank you to all who have helped and those who choose to remain with this endeavor despite the naysayers and the manure piles elsewhere.

kcq

Member

tamara said:
I can get a website hosted by Wordpress, for example. They provide the infrastructure to run my website, but the fact that they host it gives them no rights to decide who should run my site, or how to run it, or even ownership of it's contents. Hosting doesn't mean managing, never has been.

And if you violate their terms of service you are out of the platform. The company can decide what is within TOS and what violates it. You can try to dispute, but the company has the final word in it.

tamara said:
Have you read the contract that MakeFox sent to the e6ai team ? It's on e6ai discord, if you're curious. It is a quite enlightening read, and shares a new light on what MakeFox says here : https://blep.art/Blep-Receipts.html It's also interesting that said contract wasn't published as well on that 'receipts' page.

Since you didn't give examples, I will have to guess which exact clauses are supposed to be problematic.

> The Company owns blep.art: the domain, the site, the software, the infrastructure,
> all data (user, content and moderation records), and the brand.

This is poorly worded: of course the company owns the literal physical 0/1 bits that represent data, but company can not possibly assume literally full ownership of user data because of laws.
Otherwise this just describes technical state of things.

> The Company has final say on all matters affecting the site. That includes content
> policy, legal compliance, privacy, security, infrastructure and software.

This also seems mostly technical to me. Legal compliance, privacy, security infrastructure arern't part of the drama.
Software is a part of the drama, and while as a programmer I understand the reasons for disagreement here, I don't see why this would be the reason for such conflict.
Content policy can be a big discussion. But, well, we already know this was the main reason for conflict, it's literally written in the first post of this forum topic, I didn't need to read the contract to learn this.

Everything else in the contract seems completely technical, and can be summarized to "Volunteers rule the site".
Overall the contract seems very grounded, without legalese. Which is probably the reason why the first clause is poorly worded.

I don't see how reading the contract can "share a new light" here. Maybe you could provide a direct quote if I missed something important.

Some people aren't used to typical corporate contracts... I am. Have been for decades. That's why all this pearl- or egg-clutching is basically an eyeroll for me.

draco18s said:
That dispute clause is absolutely untenable. At least arbitration has the veneer of neutrality. This clause is basically a giant "fuck you" to the previous moderation team and stinks of bad faith negotiation. "You have a problem? We decide how to resolve it. If you don't like it you can leave. If we don't like it, we can make you leave."

Welcome to the real world? I'm not sure how you find a policy that basically exists in every single company on Earth as "untenable".
Ownership is ownership. Authority is authority.
The one keeping the lights on typically has both in 99.9% of all organizations.
I really just don't think the drama occurring makes any sense at this point, and the unfortunate part of it is that the old staff want to have their cake and to eat it too.

sarukmaktao said:
"- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost." <- pat_furring

This is actually something I've faced before, and something I'm looking to handle differently here. I have already contacted one user about a minor issue, and asked if they could fix. They did, I replaced the image, and now it's still up with same tags, likes, etc, just with the minor issue quietly fixed. Problem solved.

If it's a more glaring issue, unfortunately we don't have much plan for that yet, I deleted a picture with an obviously missing finger (gap between two other fingers where one should be) and that one, just re-upload, I think?

We're still working on figuring out how to handle the job left behind for us... But I recommended to the admin group we look into more supportive policies to encourage users, rather than punishing for small issues. I'm open to hearing suggestions too, and we have our telegram group. Suggestions welcome!

Can say how E6AI handled it. They made a Discord bot that would take the image and, if approved, replace it. Not sure about the techincal side of things. Just that it works.

Soul

Member

kaltingale said:
You see these types of comments again and again. From different people, from different times and different situations. All of them describing how the users were faced with unfair treatment and even attempting to fix things amounts to nothing in many of these cases. And yet, Jello comes out and says "We always treated everyone fairly". If that doesn't show you what kind of person he and his team are, I don't know what else to tell you.

One of the users got their submission deleted for "3 vs 4 toes". They showed the mod team a half transparent layer where it was clearly visible that one toe is simply obstructed by the character's foot. The janitor disregarded it and said that this is still a "3 vs 4 toes situation" and kept the submission deleted. That's far from the only time this kind of situation happened where staff failed to acknowledge how perspectives work and that the object not being visible doesn't mean it doesn't exist. That makes me think it was either an excuse to powertrip and frustrate the users, or the staff seriously lacks any fundamental understanding of art basics.

And don't even get me started on how one of the submissions got deleted for "poor anus details" on a fully inpainted and edited image. The anus looked like any other you see in furry art. There was objectively nothing wrong with it. What else this could be if not an attempt to attack the creator and discourage them from posting?

I knew jannies are fond of powertripping, but that seems so inane. Sheesh lol. Maybe Hinoserm ripped the band-aid off with them sooner rather than later.

soul said:
I knew jannies are fond of powertripping, but that seems so inane. Sheesh lol. Maybe Hinoserm ripped the band-aid off with them sooner rather than later.

Pretty much. The 'appointed' demigods ran into a more powerful force.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
From e6AI's own TOS...

[snip cuz it's long]

Alright, I stand corrected then.

I still feel like e621 and e6ai are a way bigger cost than your run-of-the-mill graphics design department. Probably not in terms of raw money, but in terms of percentage of the overall costs to the company when compared to their earnings.

tamara said:
Alright, I stand corrected then.

I still feel like e621 and e6ai are a way bigger cost than your run-of-the-mill graphics design department. Probably not in terms of raw money, but in terms of percentage of the overall costs to the company when compared to their earnings.

You're right in that they cost more than a graphics design department. They're the print version of the publishing and distribution. The Dragonfruit graphics design department makes the banners. The Home Depot graphics designs department makes the markup for the ad. E6 is the eyeball grabber, just like the physical print and distribution. The graphics design is cheap. The distribution costs per print just like the sites watch clickthrough and view count.

kaltingale said:
Just to make things clear, I'm not arguing with you, but expanding on your post.

No worries, I knew what you were saying. I agree with all that. Alienating one part of the userbase to avoid alienating another part of the userbase when blacklists exists is... either sheer stupidity, or just straight-up lying to use as a moral smokescreen to avoid coming out and saying "We don't like X. You're not allowed to have X. But we're gonna tell you that it's actually everyone else who doesn't want X and you're a bad person for making them feel bad."

sarukmaktao said:
"- Uploads were deleted first, leaving creators an opportunity to fix the issues only afterwards. By then, their position on the "New Posts" page and initial visibility were already lost." <- pat_furring

This is actually something I've faced before, and something I'm looking to handle differently here. I have already contacted one user about a minor issue, and asked if they could fix. They did, I replaced the image, and now it's still up with same tags, likes, etc, just with the minor issue quietly fixed. Problem solved.

In that vein, E6ai had users go to their Discord and use a bot command that allowed them to put in a replacement request that could be used on deleted (or not) images, that would then be reviewed and rejected or accepted by staff and used to replace the image on site. I know you guys are new to the code of this site and how it works, but it there any possiblity of considering adding something similar like a "replacement request" function on image pages on the sidebar where the flag and report buttons are? Have the newly submitted replacement image held hidden on the page where only staff can see it to judge if it meets the quality requirements or not. That way users can submit fixed images, but without having to join a Discord or Telegram channel?

Updated

sijah said:
No worries, I knew what you were saying. I agree with all that. Alienating one part of the userbase to avoid alienating another part of the userbase when blacklists exists is... either sheer stupidity, or just straight-up lying to use as a moral smokescreen to avoid coming out and saying "We don't like X. You're not allowed to have X. But we're gonna tell you that it's actually everyone else who doesn't want X and you're a bad person for making them feel bad."

In that vein, E6ai had users go to their Discord and use a bot command that allowed them to put in a replacement request that could be used on deleted (or not) images, that would then be reviewed and rejected or accepted by staff and used to replace the image on site. I know you guys are new to the code of this site and how it works, but it there any possiblity of considering adding a similar like a "replacement request" function on image pages on the sidebar where the flag and report buttons are? Have the newly submitted replacement image held hidden on the page where only staff can see it to judge if it meets the quality requirements or not. That way users can submit fixed images, but without having to join a Discord or Telegram channel?

At the moment, I can replace stuff manually. Just DM me on site and I'll help!

kcq said:
And if you violate their terms of service you are out of the platform. The company can decide what is within TOS and what violates it. You can try to dispute, but the company has the final word in it.

That's true. But if I appoint you as a mod on my website, Wordpress cannot just decide to remove you, they have no say on that side of business. MakeFox basically wanted that right with little regard for the opinion of the current team.:

9. Volunteer membership
• The Company may appoint, suspend or remove Volunteers.
• Existing volunteers may recommend additions, replacements, or removals, but may
not make those changes themselves.

kcq said:
I don't see how reading the contract can "share a new light" here. Maybe you could provide a direct quote if I missed something important.

My bad, you're right, I should have provided examples.

The two examples you've shown are some of the problems : badly worded stuff becomes law once written down and signed, until lawyers get involved. And those were very badly worded, and not something anyone could or should agree to.

The main thing that jumped to me while reading this contract is that there were 'the company decides' plastered everywhere, and it felt like volunteers were just there to do the grunt work without their input being valued and even really taken into consideration. Which is not the way to run a team that work efficiently. I know there's plenty of business that work that way, and then they wonder why they have huge turnout and very low motivation...

Like this :

6. Changing content policy
• A content-policy change starts as a written proposal from the Company, followed by a discussion period with the Volunteers (suggested, but not mandatory: 14 days).
• After the discussion, the Company decides. Its decision is final

So, basically, MakeFox will propose a change to policy, allow a discussion period, then change the policy as they want it because they decide anyway. Why even bother with the discussion period ?
And there's no room for content policy change initiated or even proposed by the team, it has to come from the MakeFox.

Or this :

5. Company obligations
• Notice of changes. The Company posts planned user-facing or volunteer-facing changes in the notice channel before they ship. Urgent security and legal fixes may ship first and be posted right after.

They'll gracefully warn the team of changes before they do them, unless they deem it urgent enough. No input asked, no discussion with the people who have run the site for years, no discussion with the community at large about the changes, just a notice, like when the city is doing some works on the road or whatever.

Or this :

8. Technical review
• Volunteer developers may review code, suggest changes and contribute through the repository.
• Their review is advisory. It cannot veto or block a Company change.

Even though DRLa knows at least part of the code, has worked with it for a while, and was, as far as I know, in touch with e621 main coder and working with them on some of the changes.

And the cherry on top :

10. Disputes
• Disputes go first to the two points of contact.
• If they're unresolved, the Company decides.
• If a Volunteer will not accept a Company decision, they may step down. Blocking implementation is not an option.

Not even an inkling of trying to maintain a pretence of caring by trying to get the disputes resolved through a neutral party.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
You're right in that they cost more than a graphics design department. They're the print version of the publishing and distribution. The Dragonfruit graphics design department makes the banners. The Home Depot graphics designs department makes the markup for the ad. E6 is the eyeball grabber, just like the physical print and distribution. The graphics design is cheap. The distribution costs per print just like the sites watch clickthrough and view count.

I would be very interested in knowing how much of the traffic going through e621 and e6ai jumps to BD through one of their ads. Unfortunately, they're probably never going to tell that number publicly...

tamara said:
That's true. But if I appoint you as a mod on my website, Wordpress cannot just decide to remove you, they have no say on that side of business. MakeFox basically wanted that right with little regard for the opinion of the current team.:

9. Volunteer membership
• The Company may appoint, suspend or remove Volunteers.
• Existing volunteers may recommend additions, replacements, or removals, but may
not make those changes themselves.

My bad, you're right, I should have provided examples.

The two examples you've shown are some of the problems : badly worded stuff becomes law once written down and signed, until lawyers get involved. And those were very badly worded, and not something anyone could or should agree to.

The main thing that jumped to me while reading this contract is that there were 'the company decides' plastered everywhere, and it felt like volunteers were just there to do the grunt work without their input being valued and even really taken into consideration. Which is not the way to run a team that work efficiently. I know there's plenty of business that work that way, and then they wonder why they have huge turnout and very low motivation...

Like this :

6. Changing content policy
• A content-policy change starts as a written proposal from the Company, followed by a discussion period with the Volunteers (suggested, but not mandatory: 14 days).
• After the discussion, the Company decides. Its decision is final

So, basically, MakeFox will propose a change to policy, allow a discussion period, then change the policy as they want it because they decide anyway. Why even bother with the discussion period ?
And there's no room for content policy change initiated or even proposed by the team, it has to come from the MakeFox.

Or this :

5. Company obligations
• Notice of changes. The Company posts planned user-facing or volunteer-facing changes in the notice channel before they ship. Urgent security and legal fixes may ship first and be posted right after.

They'll gracefully warn the team of changes before they do them, unless they deem it urgent enough. No input asked, no discussion with the people who have run the site for years, no discussion with the community at large about the changes, just a notice, like when the city is doing some works on the road or whatever.

Or this :

8. Technical review
• Volunteer developers may review code, suggest changes and contribute through the repository.
• Their review is advisory. It cannot veto or block a Company change.

Even though DRLa knows at least part of the code, has worked with it for a while, and was, as far as I know, in touch with e621 main coder and working with them on some of the changes.

And the cherry on top :

10. Disputes
• Disputes go first to the two points of contact.
• If they're unresolved, the Company decides.
• If a Volunteer will not accept a Company decision, they may step down. Blocking implementation is not an option.

Not even an inkling of trying to maintain a pretence of caring by trying to get the disputes resolved through a neutral party.

I think the key point is that we were never offering to just host a site for someone else.

The initial discussion, I'm not sure if it made it into that chat log or not, I very clearly said that we intended to make something like this even before the other team reached out, to fill the void we saw coming when e6ai closed.

I may not have articulated it clearly, but the deal was always that we would own this, and they would be volunteers working on our behalf.

It wasn't "their site", regardless of however much freedom they felt like BD gave them, that company owned everything and have the exact same control we were asking for even if they never acted on it. I know for them it must feel like they do, because they were the ones that put in the work to build build it's public image and curate it over the years, but at the end of the day, BD had final say (as is obvious from the fact that it's shutting down now)

If they wanted a hosting provider then they should have looked for one, and been willing to pay for it. That was never the offer we extended or intended to extend.

hinoserm said:
I think the key point is that we were never offering to just host a site for someone else.

The initial discussion, I'm not sure if it made it into that chat log or not, I very clearly said that we intended to make something like this even before the other team reached out, to fill the void we saw coming when e6ai closed.

I may not have articulated it clearly, but the deal was always that we would own this, and they would be volunteers working on our behalf.

It wasn't "their site", regardless of however much freedom they felt like BD gave them, that company owned everything and have the exact same control we were asking for even if they never acted on it. I know for them it must feel like they do, because they were the ones that put in the work to build build it's public image and curate it over the years, but at the end of the day, BD had final say (as is obvious from the fact that it's shutting down now)

If they wanted a hosting provider then they should have looked for one, and been willing to pay for it. That was never the offer we extended or intended to extend.

And that's the crux of the matter, as I stated in another post : a huge miscommunication about everyone's expectations. They wanted hosting, you wanted control, it was never going to work.

That being said, MakeFox should really work on their communication and the way your contracts are written. You completely missed how the team would feel after the sudden decision by BD to turn off the lights at e6ai without even having the decency of giving them advanced warning, and the way the contract was written in a very dry way and repeatedly stated 'the company decides', or a variation of it, with apparently no regards for what the team would have to say in the future was shocking for me, and I'm not on the team.

While I understand your point of view, I've run businesses myself, there's a way to do and write things, and showing that you take into account what the people working for you say and feel makes for a better work environment. This contract was the opposite of that, IMO.

I could expand on that, but it would be a huge wall of text, and it's already late for me. And what's done is done anyway.

tamara said:
And that's the crux of the matter, as I stated in another post : a huge miscommunication about everyone's expectations. They wanted hosting, you wanted control, it was never going to work.

That being said, MakeFox should really work on their communication and the way your contracts are written. You completely missed how the team would feel after the sudden decision by BD to turn off the lights at e6ai without even having the decency of giving them advanced warning, and the way the contract was written in a very dry way and repeatedly stated 'the company decides', or a variation of it, with apparently no regards for what the team would have to say in the future was shocking for me, and I'm not on the team.

While I understand your point of view, I've run businesses myself, there's a way to do and write things, and showing that you take into account what the people working for you say and feel makes for a better work environment. This contract was the opposite of that, IMO.

I could expand on that, but it would be a huge wall of text, and it's already late for me. And what's done is done anyway.

The contract came up because the board was extremely exhausted with the entire process. Immediately before it was written I was given the ultimatum that either the site goes away and the project dies or the board walks. The contract was written hastily written, yes, but it's still what the board needed to see happen or the project was dead then and there.

The contract was a compromise, to make one last attempt to keep the old team. I wasn't willing to dissolve a nonprofit over it and lose all of the other work we've done.

tamara said:
I would be very interested in knowing how much of the traffic going through e621 and e6ai jumps to BD through one of their ads. Unfortunately, they're probably never going to tell that number publicly...

Well, it's hard to differentiate between automated clickthrough (which is less these days, but can be set up), adblock which doesn't display the information as rote, and true customers. I'd imagine it's around 1/1000 to 1/5000 if norms carry over from earlier times. Print ads do better because it's something that's on someone's table for weeks at a time, but the mechanisms are entirely different so comparisons are tenuous at best. I'm used to dealing with both mediums through the years.

tamara said:
And that's the crux of the matter, as I stated in another post : a huge miscommunication about everyone's expectations. They wanted hosting, you wanted control, it was never going to work.

That being said, MakeFox should really work on their communication and the way your contracts are written. You completely missed how the team would feel after the sudden decision by BD to turn off the lights at e6ai without even having the decency of giving them advanced warning, and the way the contract was written in a very dry way and repeatedly stated 'the company decides', or a variation of it, with apparently no regards for what the team would have to say in the future was shocking for me, and I'm not on the team.

While I understand your point of view, I've run businesses myself, there's a way to do and write things, and showing that you take into account what the people working for you say and feel makes for a better work environment. This contract was the opposite of that, IMO.

I could expand on that, but it would be a huge wall of text, and it's already late for me. And what's done is done anyway.

I've worked in tech and tech-adjacent jobs (even Uncle Sam contracts) for... quite some time. "you're a peon" contracts are omnipresent... and de-facto routine. There's rarely any ambiguity that corporate overlords are the first and last to have any say in anything. But that's just my experience as an employee.

Also, I haven't and wouldn't employ anyone I think may sabotage any project I'm tasked with, in charge of, or that I as owner/corporate leader have established. To even think otherwise is a recipe for failure.

kcq

Member

tamara said:
My bad, you're right, I should have provided examples.
snip

Ok, I see what you meant, and I agree that the contract was not worded to avoid any offense to "the Volunteers", and there are indeed things that one could take as an offense.

However, I disagree that it was intentionally worded to offend anybody.
To me it feels like an intentionally dumbed-down version of real contract, with unnecessary detailes removed. Like, yeah, it could be a 30-page contract that would completely define everything that could happen, like many real ToS, and nobody in their own mind would want to read it. What we really got is the same thing, but straight to the point, without 10 pages of clarifying descriptions for all ambiguous words and a million sub-clauses for each possible outcome.

So, in my opinion taking offense from exact wording here is very silly, for the reason that this is just a standard language without standard boilerplate.

Some of the cutouts make the meaning a bit ambiguous, as you pointed out, and I agree that some interpretations look bad. However, it can be argued that interpretations more favourable to the stuff are just as valid.

The contract document shared is marked as "DRAFT v0.2" and I have not seen any evidence that MakeFox have ever stated that this contract is completely final and they will not accept any clarifications.
We don't know if any clarifications were requested, neither from MakeFox nor from the old stuff.
The only thing we know from the old stuff members is "MakeFox tried hard to get our team to sign a contract". And judging by other things I see in their discord server I assume that they have seen this draft for 1 second and immediately jumped the ship, without any further communication with MakeFox.

So while I agree that there are some issues with the contract, I think this is not from bad intents, but simply because the whole thing was very rushed, and I think jelloponies/mlem's behavior is very childish in this regard.

Updated

tamara said:
No, it's not. Where have you seen hosting work that way ? O_o

I can get a website hosted by Wordpress, for example. They provide the infrastructure to run my website, but the fact that they host it gives them no rights to decide who should run my site, or how to run it, or even ownership of it's contents. Hosting doesn't mean managing, never has been.

Have you read the contract that MakeFox sent to the e6ai team ? It's on e6ai discord, if you're curious. It is a quite enlightening read, and shares a new light on what MakeFox says here : https://blep.art/Blep-Receipts.html It's also interesting that said contract wasn't published as well on that 'receipts' page.

"a website hosted by Wordpress"

You are conflating a third-party paid resale service with non-profit foundation underwriting an entire operational ecosystem, for free.

If the former e6AI staff desire complete operational autonomy, they are entirely free to rent an independent VPS, deploy the open-source e621ng code, and self-host. But they will still be bound by that commercial host's AUP—and mainstream providers will terminate adult gallery instances the moment payment or legal liability is scrutinized.

"but the fact that they host it gives them no rights to decide [...] how to run it"

It does. It absolutely does. That is literally what an AUP is for.

WordPress is an outsourced commercial vendor leasing server space to a paying customer. Commercial hosts don't manage your staff because they are not the publisher; they only exercise negative control through their Acceptable Use Policy, which still gives them the legal right to delete your content and terminate your service at their sole discretion.

MakeFox manages the staff because MakeFox is the platform.

"Hosting doesn't mean managing"

In this case, MakeFox is not an outsourced vendor—they are the platform owner, publisher, and infrastructure provider. They registered the domain, built the hardware, uploaded the content, and absorbed 100% of the legal liability. Proprietary platform owners manage their own sites.

"Have you read the contract that MakeFox sent to the e6ai team"

Yes, in full. To anyone with an ounce of hosting experience, it is a perfectly standard, legally-mandatory contract for any website manager that does not want to be sued into bankruptcy for hosting a platform they have no direct control over.

"It's also interesting that said contract wasn't published as well on that 'receipts' page."

The receipts page openly features MakeFox's staff and AI assistant explicitly confirming that the charter was an owner's operating agreement reserving final say, not an equal partnership. The contract does not contradict the receipts; it corroborates them.

Updated

tamara said:

6. Changing content policy
• A content-policy change starts as a written proposal from the Company, followed by a discussion period with the Volunteers (suggested, but not mandatory: 14 days).
• After the discussion, the Company decides. Its decision is final

So, basically, MakeFox will propose a change to policy, allow a discussion period, then change the policy as they want it because they decide anyway. Why even bother with the discussion period ?
And there's no room for content policy change initiated or even proposed by the team, it has to come from the MakeFox.

The same reason the leader of a country has advisors despite having the final say themself. The leader is surrounded by experts in their fields that have knowledge and experience that the leader likely does not. The discussion period enables the advisors to bring to the leader's attention things that they very well may not have considered. The leader and the advisors' goals are (ideally) aligned, so if a well-informed advisor comes forward in good faith with something that needs changing, it will usually be in the leader's interest to hear them out and get the ball rolling. The benefit of having one person with the final say is that actions can be taken more quickly. Decisions don't need to get so gummed up with bureaucracy and polls and grace periods at every turn.

tamara said:
They wanted hosting, you wanted control, it was never going to work.

Both parties have already clarified this.
The e6ai team wanted free hosting and full control.
MakeFox wanted a similar website regardless of team or method, using their already present infrastructure.

That being said, MakeFox should really work on their communication and the way your contracts are written.

Regardless of communication expertise or professionalism, just because someone's feelings are hurt doesn't make it illegal nor short contracts bad business, in fact it was that contract that clarified the options for both parties leading to the decision.

The e6ai team, as senior and knowledgeable as they may be are volunteers. No more say-so than a guest at your home has.

Updated

I'm now wondering what the professional experience of the e6ai janitors is, because as many others have said the TOS is extremely standard for anything corporate, both for users as well as volunteer janitors. And remember, a volunteer isn't even a paid employee so there's that much less of a connection.

I've worked a lot of corporate jobs myself and the terms are normal, they're so ordinary as to be unremarkable. I've even run community boards myself for billion dollar companies with global reach, had community members doing volunteer work as key contributors, and even in that environment with lots of real money at stake the TOS was nearly identical.

In any corporate environment the boss has absolute power because they're paying all the bills. A wise boss listens to the feedback from people on lower rungs, this is critically important, but ultimately it is the boss' final decision. In this case, its MakeFox's decision.

IMO, I do think this is both perhaps a miscommunication where maybe both sides were too quick on the draw, but also at the same time the e6ai janitors kind of do need to remember their place. There's not any real gentle way to put it, the work they do is important, but also they're just volunteers, not even employees.

But also because of the immediate hostilities its probably impossible to rebuild that trust. Why would you trust a volunteer who has already gone on the warpath against you?

So the whole thing started from a misunderstanding, but unfortunately in that process the bridge has been burnt. And e6ai janitors are holding none of the cards, zero negotiating power.

The whole mess could have probably been avoided had these conversations happened directly face to face (or at least through streaming chat) and people not jumped to conclusions. Its all extremely unfortunate.

tamara said:

5. Company obligations
• Notice of changes. The Company posts planned user-facing or volunteer-facing changes in the notice channel before they ship. Urgent security and legal fixes may ship first and be posted right after.

They'll gracefully warn the team of changes before they do them, unless they deem it urgent enough. No input asked, no discussion with the people who have run the site for years, no discussion with the community at large about the changes, just a notice, like when the city is doing some works on the road or whatever.

Obviously the security and legal fixes will be shipped without notice if they are important enough. These type of things happen ALL the time on websites, and you won't hear about it. Most of the staff wouldn't. I'd bet money that BD's PAID developer who worked the backend of E6ai pushed changes and security fixes without consulting the volunteers on E6ai. Because it was their responsibility.

For the other changes - how often do websites talk to communities about changes and ask for their input beforehand? Not often. I'm not saying consulting the staff wouldn't have been good, but my assumption is that posting it in the notice channel allows for comments and input.

tamara said:

8. Technical review
• Volunteer developers may review code, suggest changes and contribute through the repository.
• Their review is advisory. It cannot veto or block a Company change.

Even though DRLa knows at least part of the code, has worked with it for a while, and was, as far as I know, in touch with e621 main coder and working with them on some of the changes.

To my knowledge from the screenshots, Jello stated they would need a sysadmin, as the one for the site was paid by BD. Hino stated he'd serve in that role - a role I'd point out is not something small, takes considerable time and effort - in addition to running everything else he runs and works on. I don't know DRLa myself - other than what is in the screenshots, but typically if someone is going to be the sysadmin (which it seemed like Jello was okay with at first) - obviously Hino would have final say on code getting implimented - just like BD's sysadmin likely did.

tamara said:
And the cherry on top :

10. Disputes
• Disputes go first to the two points of contact.
• If they're unresolved, the Company decides.
• If a Volunteer will not accept a Company decision, they may step down. Blocking implementation is not an option.

Not even an inkling of trying to maintain a pretence of caring by trying to get the disputes resolved through a neutral party.

I do agree the the language here is harsh - but it was ultimately just setting up the chain of command that would need to be established. Who has final say in a dispute? What kind of neutral party would you suggest? A random member of the community?

Personally, I think the language in the contract could have been softened a bit, but I don't think anything would have ever solved it. The E6ai team didn't want a partner who wanted be involved with the site. They wanted a host that would take on the cost, liability and sysadmin work and let them go on as they have for years.

And MakeFox didn't want a website to just add to their group. They wanted something they could grow, change and shape. MakeFox's team was clear that they would have eventually made a site similar to this in the future. BD dropping e6ai just put an opportunity out there.

jasper said:
And MakeFox didn't want a website to just add to their group. They wanted something they could grow, change and shape. MakeFox's team was clear that they would have eventually made a site similar to this in the future. BD dropping e6ai just put an opportunity out there.

Just my two cents on my opinion on the whole thing. Building a website from scratch and cultivating it from the very beginning is very different from taking over other people's blood and sweat and hard work.

There would not be any E6ai or this website today and its community without the blood and sweat of the Original E6ai staff. They cultivated E6ai from the very beginning to where it is now using their own time without any payment whatsoever. They spent all their free time building the website and the community behind it and its reputation.

There are people who complain about their rules and strict uploading policy but it was because of that why the website grew strong the way it was. There are other websites who are very lax about their uploading policies and you don't see much mentions of them and not much traffic there because of it.

What they were fighting for was what the community loved about it and what made it the way it is. They wanted to preserve it to the best they could in what was supposed to be its new home.

It was basically kicking a dog while it was down and then taking everything it had before leaving it in a dark corner to lick its wounds.

chaosai said:
Just my two cents on my opinion on the whole thing. Building a website from scratch and cultivating it from the very beginning is very different from taking over other people's blood and sweat and hard work.

There would not be any E6ai or this website today and its community without the blood and sweat of the Original E6ai staff. They cultivated E6ai from the very beginning to where it is now using their own time without any payment whatsoever. They spent all their free time building the website and the community behind it and its reputation.

There are people who complain about their rules and strict uploading policy but it was because of that why the website grew strong the way it was. There are other websites who are very lax about their uploading policies and you don't see much mentions of them and not much traffic there because of it.

What they were fighting for was what the community loved about it and what made it the way it is. They wanted to preserve it to the best they could in what was supposed to be its new home.

It was basically kicking a dog while it was down and then taking everything it had before leaving it in a dark corner to lick its wounds.

Um.... nice fiction, but e6 series grew out of Danbooru.

I also have no doubt they poured their volunteer resources into it. When I build a company, I do similarly. But when I sell the company, it's no longer mine, especially if I refuse to work with the people buying it.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
Um.... nice fiction, but e6 series grew out of Danbooru.

They're obviously not talking about the codebase/framework.

dfy6c said:
They're obviously not talking about the codebase/framework.

How else do you build a website from scratch? I used to start with a blank *.txt file. Yes, I'm that old.

da_reel_digitaltf said:
How else do you build a website from scratch? I used to start with a blank *.txt file. Yes, I'm that old.

I was never talking about the code. I was talking about the e6ai website itself and the community that was built around it. Without the original E6ai staff to run and maintain the original E6ai, with their free time, you and I and every one here wouldn't be here at all.

If you want a website to have a community and a good reputation, you have to pour everything you have into it and that's what the original e6ai staff did.

This website exists here because they poured all their free time into it and the users who are here right now are here because of THEM. Their hard work and dedication to maintaining and cultivating the original E6ai site from the very beginning.

Updated

chaosai said:

There are people who complain about their rules and strict uploading policy but it was because of that why the website grew strong the way it was. There are other websites who are very lax about their uploading policies and you don't see much mentions of them and not much traffic there because of it.

Excuse me, but what an absolute cope. I personally use another place to upload my stuff which has uploading guidelines allowing more freedom than e6ai ever did, as well as hosts both real and AI art, yet it has much, much bigger traffic than e6ai even when it comes to AI works AND their place is primarily fixed on a niche topic and doesn't even allow regular porn, mind you. Nobody there whines half a day about AI being allowed, things are approved in a timely manner (sometimes literally 2 minutes after the upload), while the place gets roughly 1-2 uploads per MINUTE. e6ai had 130 a DAY on average. Just because you never heard of it doesn't mean it's unpopular.

And e6ai never "grew up strong" because of policies that were objectively too strict for many users. It grew big because of the association with BD and e621, also thanks to being heavily advertised on a huge FurryDiffusion discord server with over 30 thousand members, where they even had a dedicated channel for discussing e6ai and it was also a place to contact staff before they made their own server. Ask anyone where to find furry porn and the first things you'll be told is to go to e621. Not furaffinity, not DeviantArt, not some other booru or r34 websites. And same thing ends up happening to e6ai thanks to e621 and BD popularity, not because of some fantasy where the old team built an undying and wonderful legacy. If anything, they left a huge portion of their userbase frustrated and alienated them, reducing the traffic to these measly 130 uploads themselves. I alone personally know about 10 directors that quit e6ai precisely because of how they were treated by former staff, maybe even more than 10, which isn't a small number if you ask me considering the place is pretty niche thanks to being AI focused. Any additional director counts imo. And when I first came to e6ai I was easily getting anything between 300-600 upvotes on my stuff. Since that day, it's been reduced to 100-300 upvotes in most cases, even though my stuff grew in quality quite a bit. They were actively killing the place rather than anything else and a big portion of the community shares this sentiment. Sure, you can try to explain that by a big number of effort geners appearing to sway and divide the attention between artworks, but I don't believe it would've reduced the amount of traffic my stuff gets by 2 to 3 times.

There is a reason the place was reduced down to being called "bestiality heaven" rather than a place for AI directors to thrive.

Updated

chaosai said:
I was never talking about the code. I was talking about the e6ai website itself and the community that was built around it. Without the original E6ai staff to run and maintain the original E6ai, with their free time, you and I and every one here wouldn't be here at all.

If you want a website to have a community and a good reputation, you have to pour everything you have into it and that's what the original e6ai staff did.

This website exists here because they poured all their free time into it and the users who are here right now are here because of THEM. Their hard work and dedication to maintaining and cultivating the original E6ai site from the very beginning.

Don't forget though that you just don't understand how the sausage gets made. Its not a matter of community, but rather ownership and rights. They may have spent long hours looking after things, fostering a vibe, and cultivating the space but they wanted a say in things which was unacceptable./s

Honestly it sounds like folks jumped into bed with one another too quickly. MakerFox look like disney villains, reinforced by the number of folk spouting off about corporate realities, and seemingly ignorant of those optics in the current climate, within a niche furry internet community. The old E6ai volunteers were desperate and didn't vet the partner before taking them to bed and look naive.

Because of all that we have a decisive split in the community and the anti's are having a proper laugh at our collective expense.